IJA_2026v16n5

International Journal of Aquaculture, 2026, Vol.16, No.5, 362-377 http://www.aquapublisher.com/index.php/ija 369 over 20 years, against 1.12 for a similar system built with locally sourced components (Benjamin et al., 2020, as summarized by Obirikorang et al., 2021). This is a descriptive comparison of two configurations from a single pilot study, and no statistical test is reported for the difference, which should therefore be read as indicative rather than as a statistically demonstrated effect. Economic outcomes therefore remain conditional on system scale, energy costs, the origin of construction materials, and market access. 4.4.4 Environmental performance A major documented environmental benefit is improved water-use efficiency: recirculating aquaponic systems can achieve water-use efficiency gains of up to about 90% compared with conventional production (Ibrahim et al., 2023), although actual reuse rates depend on system design, climate, and sludge and discharge management and are not equally high across designs; this is a major asset in arid and semi-arid regions (Egypt, the Sahel). Effluent recovery also reduces nitrogen and phosphorus discharge into the environment compared with conventional flow-through ponds (Goda et al., 2024). Greenhouse gas balances remain poorly documented in the African context and constitute an important research gap, particularly for systems dependent on pumps powered by electricity grids dominated by fossil fuels or by generators. 4.4.5 Social performance Acceptability and perception studies, including research in Ethiopia on willingness to pay a premium for aquaponic products, indicate growing interest among urban consumers in these products, perceived as healthier and more sustainable. Initiatives such as the YISA programs in Kenya and school-based aquaponics programs support the participation of young people and women, job creation, and technical-skills development (Odende et al., 2022; Opiyo et al., 2023; Kaminski et al., 2024; Outa et al., 2024). However, access to land, credit, and training remains unevenly distributed by gender and age (Adam and Njogu, 2023; Mudashiru et al., 2025; Ouko et al., 2026). Selected fish-production and agronomic performance ranges are summarized in Table 3. 5 Nutrient Management The performance and sustainability of integrated systems depend on effective management of nitrogen, phosphorus, and carbon cycles between compartments (Mugwanya et al., 2021; Goda et al., 2024). Nitrogen ingested by fish in protein form is largely excreted as ammonia, converted through microbial nitrification into nitrite and then nitrate, a nitrogen form directly assimilable by plants. Nitrification concerns only the nitrogen pathway; it does not transform phosphorus, which is excreted mainly in particulate form (feces and uneaten feed) and is released as dissolved phosphate essentially through the mineralization of solids. Phosphorus often accumulates in sludge and requires specific management (settling, composting, recovery as solid fertilizer). Organic carbon, supplied by uneaten feed and feces, feeds both heterotrophic bacterial biomass (particularly in biofloc systems) and, after composting or anaerobic digestion, can be recovered as organic soil amendment or biogas (Oyebola and Olatunde, 2019; Maulu et al., 2021). These nutrient pathways are illustrated in Figure 3. Table 3 Comparative summary of reported fish-production and agronomic performance (indicative ranges from the reviewed corpus; values depend on species, stocking density, feed, water quality, energy supply, and system scale, and are not directly comparable across studies) Indicator Conventional pond aquaculture Integrated aquaculture (IAA) Aquaponics Tilapia feed conversion ratio (FCR) 1.5-2.2 1.3-1.9 1.2-1.8 Survival rate 70%-90% 75%-92% 80%-95% Associated plant yield Not applicable / marginal Variable (riverside market gardening) Comparable to hydroponics, subject to mineral supplementation Water consumption (relative) High (frequent renewal) Moderate (partial reuse) Low net water demand under recirculating operation Dependence on external inputs High (feed, fertilizer) Moderate (by-products recovered) Moderate to high (electricity, feed)

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjQ4ODYzNA==