IJA_2026v16n5

International Journal of Aquaculture, 2026, Vol.16, No.5, 362-377 http://www.aquapublisher.com/index.php/ija 368 local leafy vegetables such as amaranth round out the range of species tested. A limited body of research has examined the adaptation of traditional African crops (okra, amaranth, moringa) to aquaponic conditions, even though these species show strong nutritional and cultural potential. The main aquatic and plant species reported in these systems are summarized in Table 2. Table 2 Main aquatic and plant species used in integrated/aquaponic systems in Africa (Mchunu et al., 2018; Ouko et al., 2023; Ibrahim et al., 2023; Farm Africa, 2024; Madkour et al., 2025; Mthiyane, 2025) Category Most reported species Areas/countries where they dominate Fish Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus), African catfish (Clarias gariepinus) Across the continent (Egypt, Nigeria, Kenya, Ghana, Uganda, South Africa) Secondary fish species Carp (Cyprinus carpio, Chinese carp) North Africa, rice-fish farming systems Crustaceans Freshwater shrimp and penaeids (marginal) East and southern Africa (coastal trials) Leafy vegetables Lettuce, spinach/amaranth, cabbage Urban and peri-urban NFT/DWC systems Solanaceae / fruit crops Tomato, cucumber, pepper Egypt, South Africa, Kenya Herbs Basil, mint High-value commercial systems Traditional crops Okra, moringa West Africa (still scarcely documented) 4.4 System performance 4.4.1 Zootechnical performance Growth performance reported for Tilapia and catfish in integrated or aquaponic systems was generally comparable to that in well-managed conventional tanks and was sometimes better, provided water quality (dissolved oxygen, ammonia, pH) is controlled. Reported feed conversion ratios (FCR) for tilapia in the reviewed studies generally range between about 1.2 and 1.8, depending on diet, stocking density, temperature, and system design; for example, FCR values of 1.28 for Nile tilapia and 1.42 for African catfish (monoculture units), against a cumulative FCR of 0.90 for the whole multi-trophic system, were recorded in 147-day solar-powered IMTA-aquaponic trials in Egypt (Goda et al., 2024). Survival rates above 85% have been reported in biofloc trials and in RAS coupled with aquaponics, but values differ widely among studies and depend on water-quality control, stocking density, and system scale, so comparisons with conventional production should remain conditional on these factors (Oladimeji et al., 2020). Tilapia-Clarias co-culture trials in aquaponics showed no significant negative effect on the growth of either species, or on water quality, suggesting potential for system diversification (Fidji et al., 2025). In African catfish (Clarias gariepinus), controlling the carbon-to-nitrogen (C/N) ratio in biofloc systems significantly influences growth and disease resistance (Dauda et al., 2018; Mugwanya et al., 2021). 4.4.2 Agronomic performance (plant production) Plant yields in aquaponics depend heavily on nutrient availability (particularly potassium and iron, which are often limited in aquaponic process water) and on pH control. Comparative studies between conventional hydroponics and aquaponics report broadly similar lettuce yields, with results varying according to the mineral supplementation applied. Trials integrating tilapia with crops such as wheat and sugar beet on saline soils show positive effects of fish effluent on crop growth and yield, compared with chemical fertilization alone (Madkour et al., 2025; Irabor and Begho, 2026). 4.4.3 Economic performance Available economic analyses for West Africa (SANFU case study, Lagos, Nigeria; Benjamin et al., 2020) and for southern Africa (South Africa; Maucieri et al., 2021; Adeleke, 2020b), supported by evidence from small-scale systems elsewhere (Lobillo-Eguíbar et al., 2020), converge on a common finding: the economic viability of small-scale aquaponics is often constrained by the initial investment cost (structures, pumps, aeration) and by energy costs, although it may improve over the medium term through dual production (fish and vegetables) and reduced input costs (water, fertilizer). Larger-scale, better-capitalized systems may achieve faster returns on investment but remain uncommon. In West Africa, the SANFU pilot study in Lagos provides a quantitative illustration: a prototype built with imported components had a net discounted benefit-cost rate (DBCR) of 0.08

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjQ4ODYzNA==