International Journal of Aquaculture, 2026, Vol.16, No.5, 362-377 http://www.aquapublisher.com/index.php/ija 366 filter-feeding mollusks and algae), or microbial. Under this definition, rice-fish farming, fish farming-market gardening, fish-livestock farming, integrated multitrophic aquaculture (IMTA), and aquaponics (media-based and NFT/DWC) are integrated systems. Biofloc technology (BFT) is treated as a borderline case, integrated in a broad sense only: it recycles nitrogen internally through a suspended microbial compartment within the rearing unit, and is therefore a nutrient-recycling and water-saving intensification technology rather than a combination of aquaculture with another agricultural activity. It is retained in this review because it falls within the resource-recycling logic of integrated systems and was part of the search strategy, but it is considered fully integrated only when coupled with a plant-production compartment (floc-ponics, Table 1). Evidence on BFT alone is therefore interpreted as evidence for a nutrient-recycling component, not for an integrated system in a strict sense. 3.2 Aquaponics: concept and operating principles Aquaponics is a recirculating food-production system that combines the culture of aquatic organisms with the soilless cultivation of plants. Microbial communities convert ammonia excreted by aquatic animals into nitrite and subsequently nitrate, which can be absorbed by plants. Depending on the system design, nitrification occurs in a dedicated biofilter or within the plant-growing media. Plants remove part of the dissolved nutrients before the water is returned to the aquatic-animal rearing unit. Three main configurations are commonly reported: deep-water culture (DWC), nutrient film technique (NFT), and media-based systems. Hybrid configurations, including systems coupled with biofloc technology, are also being developed. In practice, aquaponic systems are only partially closed: water is lost through evaporation, plant transpiration, sludge removal, and system flushing, and nutrients often have to be supplemented, so that water-reuse and nutrient-recycling performance differ among designs (for example, recirculating NFT or DWC units versus media-based beds). The main system types and their distinguishing characteristics are summarized in Table 1. Table 1 Definitions and classification of integrated aquaculture and aquaponics systems (Udanor et al., 2022; Li et al., 2025) System Summary definition Coupled compartments Technology level Rice-fish farming Fish reared in rice paddies or canals, making use of nutrients in the water layer Rice cultivation + fish farming Low to medium Fish farming-market gardening Use of pond water and sludge from fish ponds to irrigate/fertilize market-garden crops Fish pond + market-garden plots Low Fish-livestock farming (classic IAA) Integration of terrestrial livestock (pigs, poultry) whose manure fertilizes the fish pond (phyto-zooplankton) Terrestrial livestock + fish pond Low to medium Integrated multitrophic aquaculture (IMTA) Combination of species from different trophic levels (fish, filter-feeding molluscs, algae) recycling nutrients among themselves Fish + extractive species (algae, molluscs) Medium Biofloc technology (BFT) Management of suspended bacterial communities that recycle nitrogen directly in the rearing tank, with limited or substantially reduced water exchange Integrated in the broad sense only (internal nutrient recycling); fully integrated only when coupled with plant production Rearing tank + microbial community Medium to high Media-based aquaponics Plant cultivation on inert substrate irrigated with rearing water after biofiltration Tank + biofilter + substrate bed Medium NFT / DWC aquaponics Cultivation in nutrient film or on floating rafts, in a highly technical recirculating circuit Tank + biofilter + hydroponic unit High Floc-ponics Coupling of biofloc and aquaponics to combine bacterial nitrogen recycling with plant production Biofloc tank + hydroponic unit High
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjQ4ODYzNA==