International Journal of Aquaculture, 2026, Vol.16, No.5, 315-327 http://www.aquapublisher.com/index.php/ija 325 obtaining and moving water can represent a substantial component of production expenditure. The 5-day renewal interval provides an important practical alternative because fish cultured under this treatment showed performance comparable to the 3-day treatment for several production indicators. Thus, where water resources are relatively limited or the cost of water replacement is high, extending the renewal interval to 5 days may provide a reasonable compromise between maintaining acceptable fish production and reducing the frequency of water replacement. In contrast, the 7 and 9 day intervals resulted in progressively poorer water quality and reduced fish growth, suggesting that extending the renewal interval beyond 5 days may compromise production performance under the conditions of the present study. Farmer management capacity is another important consideration in selecting an appropriate renewal interval. A 3-day renewal schedule requires farmers to monitor and maintain the system more frequently and to have reliable access to water and the necessary infrastructure for regular water replacement. Such a management regime may be more feasible for commercial or well-resourced farmers with adequate labour, water supply and pumping facilities. For smallholder farmers with limited labour, infrastructure or water access, a 5-day renewal interval may be more manageable while still supporting satisfactory production. Nevertheless, the economic implications of each renewal frequency should be evaluated under specific production environments because the present study did not directly quantify water use, labour requirements, energy consumption or operational costs. Therefore, the 3-day renewal frequency may be regarded as the biologically optimal treatment under the experimental conditions, whereas the 5-day interval may offer a potentially more practical water-saving option where resource constraints are important. Further studies incorporating water-use efficiency, production costs and labour requirements would be valuable for determining the most economically and operationally appropriate renewal frequency for different categories of aquaculture farmers. 5 Conclusion Overall, this study demonstrates that water renewal frequency is a key management factor determining the productivity of integrated aquaculture systems. Frequent water renewal maintained favourable physicochemical conditions, resulting in better fish growth, better feed utilization and improved physiological condition while simultaneously generating effluent capable of supporting enhanced plant growth. Under the experimental conditions of this study, the 3-day water renewal frequency produced the best overall fish production performance, whereas the 5-day renewal frequency showed comparable results for several production indices and exhibited favourable signs of plant health, suggesting that it may provide a practical compromise between water conservation and production efficiency. However, the recommendation of a 3-day water renewal frequency should be interpreted within the specific experimental conditions under which this study was conducted. Optimal water renewal frequency may vary depending on factors such as stocking density, tank or pond size, feed, climatic conditions, plant species, system design, and the availability and quality of water. Therefore, water renewal schedules should be adapted to local production and management conditions, with appropriate monitoring of water quality and fish and plant performance. These findings provide useful guidance for optimizing water management in integrated aquaculture systems and contribute to efforts to promote sustainable fish production and efficient resource utilization in Nigeria and other water-limited regions. Further studies under different production environments and management conditions are recommended to refine the appropriate water renewal frequency for diverse integrated aquaculture systems. Acknowledgement We sincerely thank the anonymous reviewers for constructive feedback on previous versions of the manuscript. Conflict of Interest Disclosure The authors affirm that this research was conducted without any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjQ4ODYzNA==