International Journal of Aquaculture, 2026, Vol.16, No.5, 417-435 http://www.aquapublisher.com/index.php/ija 423 4.2 Production costs and input structure The production costs of rice-fish coculture systems mainly include rice cultivation inputs, fish farming inputs, and field infrastructure construction expenses. Rice cultivation costs involve seeds, fertilizers, pesticides, and mechanized field operations, while fish farming costs primarily include fingerlings, feed, and routine management. The construction of fish ditches, refuge ponds, escape-prevention facilities, and irrigation and drainage systems represents additional initial investment. Compared with rice monoculture, rice-fish coculture can utilize existing paddy fields for fish farming, but its production processes are more complex and require greater attention to infrastructure maintenance, labor allocation, and water-level management. A meta-analysis of integrated rice-fish farming systems in Africa by Goh et al. (2024) found that average production costs under rice-fish coculture were approximately US$300/ha higher than those under rice monoculture, mainly due to expenditures on fish ditch construction, fingerling purchases, feed, and protective facilities. Cui et al. (2023) also reported that total investment costs in rice-animal coculture systems were 142% higher than those in rice monoculture, although substantial differences existed among coculture types. Among these systems, rice-fish coculture had an average investment cost of US$843 ± 159/ha, lower than that of several other coculture systems, including rice-crayfish farming. Therefore, the cost advantages of rice-fish coculture do not necessarily involve simultaneous reductions in all production inputs. Instead, an appropriate balance must be established between additional aquaculture investments and the economic returns generated by integrated production. In terms of cost structure, rice-fish coculture systems are characterized by simultaneous increases in certain expenditures and reductions in others. On the one hand, fingerling purchases, supplementary feed, aquaculture facility maintenance, and labor management increase production costs. On the other hand, fish can utilize natural food resources in paddy fields and reduce dependence on fertilizers and pesticides by promoting nutrient cycling and suppressing certain pests, diseases, and weeds. The meta-analysis by Cui et al. (2023) showed that mineral fertilizer and pesticide costs in rice-animal coculture systems decreased from US$262/ha under rice monoculture to US$187/ha, representing a reduction of approximately 29%. Goh et al. (2024) similarly indicated that rice-fish coculture could reduce some rice production costs by supplying nutrients through fish excreta and decreasing pesticide inputs. Household surveys in Indonesia also suggested that appropriately managed rice-fish coculture could reduce certain agricultural production inputs while increasing farmers' income (Mariyono, 2023). However, whether these cost savings translate into greater operational efficiency depends on production management practices. Samaddar et al. (2025) found that some rice-fish farmers obtained relatively low returns because of inefficient input management, insufficient funding, and a lack of technical training. Therefore, actual production cost assessments should also account for infrastructure depreciation, labor inputs, feed consumption, and aquaculture losses to avoid overestimating economic benefits by overlooking long-term expenditures. 4.3 Net returns and benefit-cost ratio Net returns and the benefit-cost ratio are important indicators for evaluating the economic feasibility of rice-fish coculture systems. Net returns represent the actual earnings remaining after production costs are deducted from total production value, whereas the benefit-cost ratio measures the economic output generated per unit of production input. Although rice-fish coculture requires additional investment in fish farming and field infrastructure, revenue from aquatic products can offset these additional costs under suitable conditions, thereby improving overall profitability. A global meta-analysis by Cui et al. (2023) found that the average net returns of rice-animal coculture systems increased from US$1,019/ha under rice monoculture to US$2,212/ha, with the rice-fish coculture category showing an approximately 98% increase in net returns, indicating considerable potential for income improvement. Research conducted in Africa also found that although production costs under rice-fish coculture increased by approximately US$300/ha, total revenue rose by more than US$600/ha, resulting in an average net return increase of approximately US$300/ha (Figure 1) (Goh et al., 2024). Furthermore, a comparative study of different rice production systems in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam, by Berg et al. (2023) found that a system combining two rice crops with one fish crop achieved the highest annual net income and benefit-cost ratio among the production systems evaluated. These advantages were mainly attributable to lower agrochemical
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjQ4ODYzNA==