International Journal of Aquaculture, 2026, Vol.16, No.5, 417-435 http://www.aquapublisher.com/index.php/ija 419 Growth performance varies among fish species in rice-fish coculture systems and is also influenced by species combinations, stocking density, and supplementary feeding levels. Common carp and tilapia can utilize different food resources in paddy fields, but their growth rates are not necessarily identical. Inayat et al. (2023) found that, under the same rice-fish coculture conditions, tilapia achieved an average weight gain of 303.13 g, slightly higher than the 296.41 g recorded for common carp, indicating that species-specific growth characteristics influence aquaculture performance. Similarly, Lokuhetti et al. (2025) reported that tilapia exhibited better growth performance and adaptability to paddy field conditions than common carp in Sri Lanka. In addition, Ghazi and Al-Khshali (2026) found that polyculture of common carp and grass carp at an appropriate ratio resulted in higher total weight gain and specific growth rates than monoculture treatments, suggesting that combining fish species with different feeding habits may improve resource utilization efficiency. However, as stocking density increases, competition for food and movement space may intensify, potentially limiting individual weight gain. Therefore, rice-fish coculture does not necessarily improve the growth rates of all fish species, and its aquaculture advantages largely depend on the appropriate matching of fish biological characteristics with available paddy field resources (Bashir et al., 2020; Zhu et al., 2024). 2.2 Survival rate and fish yield per unit area Fish survival rate is an important indicator for evaluating aquaculture performance in rice-fish coculture systems, directly affecting final production and economic returns. Rice plants, fish ditches, and refuge ponds in paddy fields provide fish with space for movement and shelter. However, the relatively shallow water is vulnerable to high temperatures, drought, water-level fluctuations, and pesticide application. When dissolved oxygen levels become insufficient or water quality deteriorates, fish may exhibit reduced feeding activity, impaired growth, or even mortality. Kaewpuangdee et al. (2024) found that survival rates exceeded 80% for all stocked aquatic animals in a paddy field coculture experiment involving several fish species and freshwater prawns, suggesting that properly managed paddy fields can provide relatively suitable habitats. Nevertheless, differences in fish species and stocking density can lead to substantial variations in survival rates. In a stocking-density experiment involving tilapia and common carp, Billah et al. (2020a) found that a 1:1 polyculture ratio at a stocking density of 6 fish/m² achieved a survival rate of 66.67%, higher than those recorded at densities of 4 and 8 fish/m², indicating that excessive stocking density may intensify competition and reduce survival. Lokuhetti et al. (2025) also reported an average survival rate of 74% for tilapia, compared with 64% for common carp, further demonstrating species-specific differences in adaptability to paddy field environments. Therefore, maintaining appropriate water levels, improving escape-prevention facilities, and adjusting stocking density according to fish species characteristics are essential measures for improving survival rates. Fish yield per unit area is primarily influenced by species selection, stocking density, culture duration, and food availability. A moderate increase in stocking density can increase the number of fish per unit area, whereas excessive density may lead to food shortages, reduced dissolved oxygen, and competition for living space, thereby affecting survival and individual weight gain. Through a systematic review and meta-analysis, Fernandez-Zatrate et al. (2025) reported an average fish stocking density of approximately 13,390 fish/ha in rice-fish coculture studies, with an average fish yield of 1,383 kg/ha and an average rice yield of 4,397 kg/ha, demonstrating the potential of this system to produce both grain and aquatic products on the same land area. Hu et al. (2016) investigated integrated rice-fish farming systems in China and found that increasing fish production could improve aquaculture returns. However, rice yield began to decline when fish production exceeded approximately 2.106 t/ha in rice-common carp coculture systems, whereas keeping the area occupied by fish refuge facilities below 10% generally helped maintain rice production. Therefore, compared with high-density pond aquaculture, the primary advantage of rice-fish coculture is not simply to maximize fish yield, but to increase aquatic product output while maintaining normal rice growth. Aquaculture performance should consequently be evaluated by considering fish survival rate, average individual weight, fish yield per unit area, and rice production requirements, rather than relying solely on stocking numbers to assess overall benefits.
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjQ4ODYzNA==