IJA_2026v16n5

International Journal of Aquaculture, 2026, Vol.16, No.5, 397-416 http://www.aquapublisher.com/index.php/ija 407 deterioration, thereby reducing survival rates and market-size uniformity. Wang et al. (2026b) found that intensive pond monoculture had a feed conversion ratio of 3.07 ± 0.29 and a survival rate of 89.42%, whereas the corresponding values in rice-turtle co-culture were 2.80 ± 0.27 and 95.00%, respectively. These results indicate that higher production intensity does not necessarily lead to better feed utilization or population survival. Therefore, assessments of yield per unit area should consider actual harvest weight, marketable size, and effective culture duration rather than evaluating production efficiency solely on the basis of stocking numbers. Commercial returns depend not only on turtle yield but also on marketable size, product quality, and market prices. Greenhouse culture can improve the continuity of market supply by shortening the production cycle, but whether higher yields translate into greater profits still depends on selling prices and cost control. Although pond and ecological culture generally require longer production periods, product quality differences may generate price premiums under certain market conditions. Rice-turtle co-culture can also produce both rice and turtles, thereby improving overall land productivity. Through four consecutive years of field experiments, Guo et al. (2022) found that average rice yield in rice-turtle co-culture systems increased by 8.69% compared with rice monoculture, while the average annual turtle yield reached 2.66 t/ha. These results indicate that integrated culture can increase aquatic animal production while maintaining rice productivity. Zhang et al. (2016) similarly demonstrated that rice-turtle co-culture could produce Chinese soft-shelled turtles without significantly reducing rice yield. Wang et al. (2026a) further reported that the increased net returns from rice-turtle co-culture were primarily attributable to additional revenue from turtle sales rather than solely to improvements in rice yield. Collectively, these findings suggest that the economic advantages of integrated culture mainly arise from comprehensive land utilization and multiple product revenue streams. Therefore, evaluations of commercial returns should consider the yields, selling prices, and production costs of both turtles and rice, rather than assessing the economic advantages of a culture model solely on the basis of turtle yield. 5.3 Input-output ratio and overall economic benefits The input-output ratio and net profit comprehensively reflect the relationship between financial investment and economic returns in Chinese soft-shelled turtle culture and are important indicators for evaluating the profitability of different culture models. Although intensive greenhouse culture offers advantages such as rapid growth, relatively high yields per unit area, and shorter production cycles, facility depreciation, energy consumption, and high-density management costs may reduce profit margins. Conventional pond culture generally requires lower fixed infrastructure investment, but longer culture cycles, prolonged capital occupation, and environmental fluctuations may affect actual returns. Ecological culture places greater emphasis on integrated resource utilization and production cost control, with its economic advantages largely determined by culture technologies, market conditions, and resource allocation efficiency. Liu et al. (2019) conducted an energy analysis and economic assessment of a rice-turtle-fish co-culture system and reported an energy output-input ratio of 5.17 and a net profit of CNY 98,729.96/ha, indicating that integrated culture can provide advantages in both economic performance and resource utilization. Through a meta-analysis of 224 studies on integrated rice-aquatic animal farming, Yu et al. (2023) found that integrated culture systems increased net ecological and economic benefits by 31.7%-71.1% compared with rice monoculture, while also improving soil fertility and reducing certain agricultural environmental pressures. However, these findings encompass various types of integrated rice farming systems and cannot be directly interpreted as benefits attributable exclusively to rice-turtle co-culture. Therefore, economic evaluations of different culture models should account for specific production conditions and adopt consistent cost accounting boundaries and operating periods to avoid misleading comparisons of economic returns across independent studies. Comprehensive assessments of economic benefits should also consider production risks, resource utilization, and operational stability. Wang et al. (2026b) compared intensive pond monoculture with rice-turtle co-culture and found that both systems demonstrated a certain degree of economic feasibility. However, intensive pond culture required greater initial capital investment, with an estimated investment payback period of approximately 4.7 years, making it more suitable for large-scale producers with sufficient financial resources and strong technical

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjQ4ODYzNA==