International Journal of Aquaculture, 2026, Vol.16, No.5, 397-416 http://www.aquapublisher.com/index.php/ija 405 4.3 Differences in product quality and nutritional composition Product quality is an important indicator of the overall benefits of Chinese soft-shelled turtle culture and is influenced by multiple factors, including culture environment, dietary composition, developmental stage, and activity level. Different culture models affect muscle nutritional composition, tissue structure, and edible quality by altering food sources, energy allocation, and physiological status. Intensive greenhouse culture provides a stable feed supply and controllable growth conditions, facilitating rapid growth and the attainment of marketable size. However, relatively restricted movement and higher feeding intensity may alter nutrient deposition in body tissues. In contrast, pond culture and rice-turtle co-culture provide more diverse environmental structures and food sources, potentially resulting in different tissue compositions and nutritional characteristics. Qi et al. (2025) compared greenhouse, pond, and rice-paddy culture models and found that greenhouse-cultured turtles exhibited higher relative proportions of liver, viscera, and internal fat, whereas pond- and rice-paddy-cultured turtles had higher proportions of carapace, calipash, and edible parts. Regarding muscle nutritional composition, crude protein, total amino acids, essential amino acids, flavor-related amino acids, collagen, and EPA+DHA contents were significantly higher in the pond and rice-paddy groups than in the greenhouse group. Conversely, the greenhouse group exhibited higher crude fat content and higher values for certain unsaturated fatty acid indicators. These findings indicate that different culture models influence nutrient accumulation in distinct ways, and product quality cannot be evaluated solely on the basis of growth rate or fat content. The product quality of Chinese soft-shelled turtles is also influenced by health status, age, and tissue type, suggesting that culture models and physiological conditions may exert combined effects. Yang et al. (2026) compared greenhouse-cultured Chinese soft-shelled turtles and found that healthy individuals generally exhibited better intestinal tissue integrity, antioxidant capacity, and muscle nutritional composition than diseased individuals. Adult turtles also showed certain advantages in crude protein, essential amino acid, and flavor-related amino acid contents. Hou et al. (2024) investigated pond-cultured male Chinese soft-shelled turtles of different ages and demonstrated age-related differences in muscle nutritional composition and flavor characteristics. Five-year-old turtles exhibited particularly favorable flavor-related amino acid profiles and volatile flavor characteristics, whereas six-year-old turtles showed higher levels of certain amino acids and EPA+DHA. Therefore, evaluations of Chinese soft-shelled turtle product quality should comprehensively consider protein, fat, amino acid and fatty acid composition, and muscle texture, while controlling potential confounding factors such as sex, age, dietary composition, and culture duration whenever possible. Overall, ecological culture models, including pond and rice-paddy culture, exhibit certain advantages in selected nutritional indicators and the proportion of edible parts, whereas greenhouse culture facilitates relatively high production efficiency. In commercial production, appropriate culture models should be selected according to market demands for product size, texture, and nutritional quality. Optimizing nutritional supply and environmental management can help achieve a balance between growth efficiency and product quality. 5 Comparison of Economic Benefits Among Different Culture Models 5.1 Production Inputs and Culture Costs Production inputs and culture costs provide an essential basis for evaluating the economic benefits of different culture models for Chinese soft-shelled turtles (Pelodiscus sinensis). These costs mainly include seedstock, feed, infrastructure construction, labor and management, water and electricity consumption, energy supply, and disease prevention and control. Different culture models vary in facility configuration, environmental control, and resource utilization, resulting in distinct cost structures (He and Zhang, 2018; Zhu et al., 2024). Conventional pond culture generally utilizes existing water bodies and requires relatively low infrastructure and energy inputs. However, natural environmental conditions and longer culture cycles may increase land occupation costs, labor requirements, and capital turnover costs. Intensive greenhouse culture maintains stable growth conditions through heating, aeration, and water quality regulation facilities, thereby improving facility utilization efficiency, but it requires substantial initial investment and continuous operating expenses. Wang et al. (2026a) compared intensive pond monoculture with rice-turtle co-culture and found that the former required more extensive infrastructure,
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjQ4ODYzNA==